SafeWork NSW | AAA Trailers Pty Ltd has been convicted and fined $225,000 in the Industrial Court of NSW as a result of a prosecution by SafeWork NSW.

The proceedings arose from an incident on 7 September 2023, when a worker suffered serious injuries after a 350 kg axle fell on him while working underneath a trailer.

AAA Trailers Pty Ltd plead guilty to an offence pursuant to section 32 of the Work Health and Safety Act 2011 for failing to comply with its health and safety duty to workers under section 19(1) of the Act.

AAA Trailers Pty Ltd has the right to appeal against its sentence.

SafeWork NSW | Toll Transport Pty Ltd has been convicted and fined $807,500 in the Industrial Court of NSW as a result of a prosecution by SafeWork NSW.

The proceedings arose from an incident on 20 December 2022, when a worker suffered serious injuries while using a crowbar to dislodge a pallet which was stuck on a conveyor machine.

Toll Transport Pty Ltd plead guilty to an offence pursuant to section 32 of the Work Health and Safety Act 2011 for failing to comply with its health and safety duty to workers under section 19(1) of the Act.

Toll Transport Pty Ltd has the right to appeal against its sentence.

SafeWork NSW | Shoring Co Pty Ltd has been convicted and fined a total of $170,000 in the Industrial Court of NSW as a result of a prosecution by SafeWork NSW.

The proceedings arose from an incident on 26 September 2022, when a concrete pump malfunctioned during pouring operations, causing concrete to spray unexpectedly.

During the incident, a traffic controller fell into an excavation pit, which was approximately 10 metres deep at its deepest point.

Shoring Co Pty Ltd pleaded guilty to two offences pursuant to section 32 of the Work Health and Safety Act 2011. The offences related to failing to ensure, respectively the health and safety of workers as required under section 19(1), and the health and safety of other persons as required under 19(2), of the Act.

Shoring Co Pty Ltd has the right to appeal against the sentence.

Government of Western Australia | Mine owner and operator FQM Australia Nickel Pty Ltd has been fined $810,000 and ordered to pay $11,096.20 in costs by the Albany Magistrates Court over an incident in which a worker suffered a serious spinal injury.

On 18 March 2023, the injured worker was carrying out maintenance on the Saprolite Stacker at FQM Australia Nickel Pty Ltd’s Ravensthorpe Nickel Operation processing plant when a heavy plant component known as a Roman Shield moved and struck him. The injured worker required spinal fusion surgery, extensive treatment, and rehabilitation.

FQM Australia Nickel Pty Ltd pleaded guilty to contravening sections 19(1) and 31(1) of the Work Health and Safety Act 2020. The company failed to comply with a health and safety duty and, by that failure, caused serious harm to a worker.

The court heard FQM Australia Nickel Pty Ltd transported nickel ore to stockpiles via conveyor stackers at the processing plant. Workers were changing out a Roman Shield on the Saprolite Stacker when the incident occurred. The injured worker and two co-workers unfastened the Roman Shield without first securing it against uncontrolled movement. The Roman Shield rotated backwards and part of it struck the injured worker, pinning him against part of the structure.

FQM Australia Nickel Pty Ltd did not instruct the workers to secure the Roman Shield before unfastening it, warn them of the risk of uncontrolled movement or instruct them to stay clear of the potential line of fire. The Job Hazard Analysis for the task did not include those controls and the allocated supervisor did not directly supervise the work.

WorkSafe Commissioner Sally North said the prosecution highlighted the importance of conducting a thorough risk assessment to identify hazards associated with high-risk tasks and implement effective controls before beginning the work.

Following the incident, FQM Australia Nickel Pty Ltd engaged a specialist safety consultant, developed Roman Shield-specific risk assessment procedures and work instructions, introduced more comprehensive Job Hazard Analyses, and enhanced training programmes for new employees and supervisors. In July 2024, the company placed the Ravensthorpe Nickel Operation into care and maintenance.

SafeWork NSW | Secura Scaffold Services Pty Ltd and director Nan Hu have been convicted and fined a total of $48,000 in the Industrial Court of NSW as a result of a prosecution by SafeWork NSW.

The proceedings arose from an incident on 29 September 2022, when members of the public were placed at risk due to an unsecured mobile scaffold.

Secura Scaffold Services plead guilty to an offence pursuant to section 33 of the Work Health and Safety Act 2011 for failing to comply with its duty under section 19(2) of the Act. The company was fined $40,000.

Mr. Hu, who was the sole director of Secura Scaffold Services, plead guilty to an offence pursuant to section 33 of the Act for failing to exercise due diligence as an officer of the business as required under section 27(1) of the Act. He was fined $8,000.

Secura Scaffold Services and Mr. Hu have the right to appeal against their sentences.

SafeWork SA | An excavator operator has been fined $15,000 following a workplace incident at a demolition site in Adelaide’s western suburbs that left a worker with life-changing injuries.

Sole trader and civil demolition contractor Josef Kovacev was convicted in the South Australian Employment Court following a SafeWork SA prosecution.

The Court found Mr. Kovacev failed to comply with his health and safety duty while operating an excavator during demolition works at a residential property in Torrensville on 15 November 2023.

The incident occurred while demolition and site clearance works were being undertaken at the property.

Mr. Kovacev had been engaged as a subcontractor to operate an excavator, while a labourer was working nearby sorting building debris.

While operating the excavator to uproot trees and gather green waste, Mr. Kovacev struck the labourer with the excavator arm and bucket.

The labourer suffered a severe crush injury to his left foot that ultimately required a partial foot amputation.

SafeWork SA’s investigation found workers could be working in close proximity to the excavator while it was operating and that there was no adequately enforced exclusion zone, communication system or spotter in place to manage the risk of workers being struck by the machine.

In his judgment, Auxiliary Judge Hannon found Mr. Kovacev failed to provide a safe working environment by failing to enforce an exclusion zone around the excavator or an appropriate system of communication between himself and workers operating nearby.

Judge Hannon found it was reasonably practicable for Mr. Kovacev to enforce an exclusion zone, establish a system of verbal or hand-signalling communication, or cease operating the excavator while workers were in the vicinity.

Judge Hannon said the excavator “came to be operating in dangerous proximity” to the labourer in circumstances where there was inadequate monitoring of an exclusion zone.

He said measures such as enforcing exclusion zones or communication systems “would have either minimised or eliminated the risk” of a worker being struck and suffering death or serious injury.

Mr. Kovacev was charged with a Category 2 offence under the Work Health and Safety Act 2012 (SA). He was convicted and fined $15,000. He was also ordered to pay SafeWork SA’s costs of $1,210 and a Victims of Crime levy of $466.

SafeWork NSW | SMB Australia Car Transport Pty Ltd, SMB Australia Car Transport Employment Pty Ltd, and director Andrew Mytkowski have been convicted and fined a total of $420,000 in the District Court of NSW as a result of a prosecution by SafeWork NSW.

The proceedings arose from an incident on 24 March 2022, when a worker sustained serious injuries when struck by an industrial gate which overran vertical supports while being closed.

SMB Australia Car Transport Employment Pty Ltd plead guilty to an offence pursuant to section 32 of the Work Health and Safety Act 2011 for failing to comply with its health and safety duty to workers under section 19(1) of the Act. The company was fined $180,000.

SMB Australia Car Transport Pty Ltd plead guilty to an offence pursuant to section 32 of the Act for failing to comply with its duty under section 21(2) of the Act. The company was fined $180,000.

Mr. Mytkowski, who was the sole director of SMB Australia Car Transport Pty Ltd and SMB Australia Car Transport Employment Pty Ltd at the time of the incident, plead guilty to two offences under section 32 of the Act for failing to exercise due diligence as an officer of both companies as required under section 27(1) of the Act. He was fined a total of $60,000.

SMB Australia Car Transport Pty Ltd, SMB Australia Car Transport Employment Pty Ltd, and Mr. Mytkowski have the right to appeal against their sentences.

SafeWork SA | A scaffolding company has been fined $6,000 after failing to comply with a formal SafeWork SA notice requiring information about safety concerns at a construction site.

Tedesco Scaffold Services Pty Ltd pleaded guilty and has been sentenced in the South Australian Employment Court following a SafeWork SA prosecution.

It is only the second time a company has been successfully prosecuted for this type of offence in South Australia.

The offence arose from the company’s failure to respond within two weeks to a formal notice issued under section 155 of the Work Health and Safety Act 2012.

The notice required the company to provide information relating to safety concerns identified by SafeWork SA inspectors at a residential construction site.

SafeWork SA inspectors attended the site on 6 October 2023 and issued prohibition and improvement notices relating to scaffolding and site safety.

On 9 November 2023, a formal section 155 notice was emailed to the company’s director, requiring specified information to be provided by 23 November 2023.

The company failed to respond within the required timeframe despite receiving the notice and subsequent reminders from inspectors.

A partial response was eventually provided months later after further contact from SafeWork SA.

In his sentencing remarks, Deputy President Lieschke found the company had committed an “objectively serious breach” of its obligation to respond to a formal notice issued by SafeWork SA.

A conviction was recorded and the company was fined $6,000. The company was also ordered to pay a victims of crime levy of $278 and SafeWork SA’s legal costs of $1,210.

SafeWork NSW | Fitzmoore Group Pty Ltd has been fined $390,000 in the Industrial Court of NSW as a result of a prosecution by SafeWork NSW.

These proceedings arose from an incident on 23 October 2023, when a worker was seriously injured after falling about three metres through a skylight void from one level to another.

Fitzmoore Group Pty Ltd pleaded guilty to an offence pursuant to section 32 of the Work Health and Safety Act 2011 for failing to comply with its health and safety duty to workers under section 19(1) of the Act.

Fitzmoore Group Pty Ltd has the right to appeal against the sentence.

WorkSafe Victoria | A water tank construction and repair company has been convicted and fined $50,000 after an engineering student was injured at a residential site in Keysborough.

JS Armstrong Water Tanks Pty Ltd was sentenced in the Dandenong Magistrates’ Court after pleading guilty to a single charge of failing to ensure a workplace under its management and control was safe and without risks to health.

The company was also ordered to pay $4,452 in costs.

The court heard JS Armstrong workers were carrying out work within a large excavation on the property in preparation for the installation of an 89,000-litre water tank.

In March 2024, a 20-year-old engineering student assisting with shovelling work at the site was leaning over the edge to pass a bottle of water into the excavation when the ground beneath her gave way.

She fell three metres into the excavation and landed on a brick, suffering a vertebral fracture, spine tenderness, and whiplash.

A WorkSafe investigation found the excavation site had no warning signs, fencing, or battering, and that soil was seen peeling away from the walls of the excavation while workers were inside.

JS Armstrong admitted it was reasonably practicable to have reduced the risk by ensuring the sides of the excavation were battered, there was a safe entry point to the excavation, and barricades or warning barriers were placed at least one metre from the edge of the excavation before any work was performed.